• June 10, 2023

Phillies Are All In For 2011

The Philadelphia Phillies are all in.

No longer an up and coming team, Ruben Amaro Jr and David Montgomery made it clear they are now one of the big boys in the MLB when they signed Cliff Lee. With that declaration came big expectations, especially from the fans that have made a $167 million dollar pay roll possible.

With the season finally arriving, it is time for the Phillies to back up all of the expectations. Here are some of my predictions for the upcoming season:

Phillies Staff of Aces-

Odds: Cy Young Odds:- Cliff Lee 7/1, Cole Hamels 10/1, Roy Halladay 7/2, Roy Oswalt 10/1, Joe Blanton N/A

The Bet: Roy Halladay

Analysis: Anytime four of the top 6 pitchers favored to win the Cy Young are in your rotation, you’re in pretty good shape. Tim Lincecum appears to be the only pitcher in the way of a Phillie taking home the award for the second year in a row, and you could make an argument for any of the “Big Four”.

Cliff Lee was dominant during his first time around with the Phillies, and would have won the CY Young that season had he pitched in the NL the whole season. Roy Oswalt is in a contract season, with a club buyout of $2 million this offseason. Oswalt was undefeated in Citizens Bank Park last season, and could rack up the wins as he will face the opposing teams 3rd best pitcher each night.

If any pitcher will benefit from facing weaker opposition it is Cole Hamels, who has gone from going up against a teams ace to a back of the order quality pitcher. Hamels has always been a victim of poor run support, but that should change this year. Hamels struggled through Spring Training, but that is nothing new. While he may give up his fair share of long balls, Hamels has a real chance at 18 wins this season, making him a serious Cy Young Candidate. As for Roy Halladay, the favorite to win the award, his numbers will only improve after having a year to learn the NL hitters.

Jimmy Rollins in Contract Year-

Odds- Batting Average Over/Under .256

The Bet: Over

Analysis: If history has taught us anything, it is that players in contract years are capable of amazing things. It has also taught us that when a player who has fight in them has something to prove, they prove it. Both of those cases apply to Jimmy Rollins this season. Rollins is a fan favorite, but most have written him off this year, citing his declining numbers over the last 4 seasons.

Yes, his best days are behind him, but Rollins came into this season in great shape after playing under 100 games last season- which is the first time since his rookie year. Rollins has played over 130 games 9 of the last 10 seasons, and 3 of the last 4. If you project his 2010 numbers over 130 games instead of 88, Rollins numbers would be comparable to the season the Phillies won the World Series, as well as his 2009 numbers. Rollins has batted under .250 only once (last season) in the past 8 seasons, so .256 is not unreasonable. I think Rollins has a bounce back year, and gets over .256- and another contract from the Phillies.

Ryan Howard Bounce Back Year-

Odds: Over/Under 35.5 hrs, 121 rbis

The Bet: Over HR’s, Under RBI

Analysis: This is a big season for Ryan Howard. The last image fans have of him is the bat sitting on his shoulder, after turning in an awful series against the Giants. Teams around the league are starting to figure him out, throwing him anything but a fastball and daring him to hit it. Howard had his worst statistical year since 2005 last season, and while many people blame that on injuries, he still played 143 games.

Howard played 144 games in 2007, but still had considerably more homeruns (47-31) and RBI’s (149-108). A key question for Howard will be protection, as his sandwich of Chase Utley and Jayson Werth are now gone. Still, Howard has hit over 45 home runs every year since 2005, so the 35 number seems low. His RBI’s will suffer from a lineup that is not what it used to be, but expect an MVP caliber season from Howard in 2011.

Record Breaking Season?

Odds: Over/Under 96.5 Wins

The Bet: Over

Analysis: Has a spring training in which a team had a winning record, and their Ace had an ERA under 1 ever scared fans more then this one? 2 months ago, any Phillies fan would have bet their life savings on their team winning over 96 games. It seemed logical, since the team had improved its victory total each year since 2006.

The Phillies won 97 games last year despite loosing Rollins, Utley and Howard for more then 140 games. They also played the first half of the season with a rotation that, besides Halladay, featured a struggling Hamels and not much else. Brad Lidge will miss time this year, but Jose Contreras was 4 for 4 last season in saves, and Madson is one of the best set up men in the game. Jayson Werth’s right handed bat will be missed, but the addition of Lee and Oswalt (for a full season) more then make up for him. Will the Phillies break the record for wins in a season? Most likely not. But they will be better then last year, which means winning over 96 games.

Can The Braves Overtake The Phillies?

Odds: Phillies Win Regular Season Series with Braves (-200)

The Bet: Braves Win Season Series

Analysis: The Braves gave the Phillies problems last season, as they actually spent more days in first then the Phillies did. The Braves offense should be better this season, as the addition of Dan Uggla will help. It will also be Jayson Heyward’s second season after an impressive rookie campaign.

Larry Bowa will tell you the Braves have better pitching then the Phillies, and while that is a stretch at best, the Braves do have one of the best rotations in the league. Last season, the Phillies went 10-8 against the Braves, scoring 78 runs against them, the 3rd most runs they scored against an opponent. While I do think the Phillies are a better team then the Braves, I think the Braves take the season series. The Phillies are a veteran team, and one that has coasted through the regular season at times. When the Phillies face the Braves, the games will mean more to Atlanta.

Can The Phillies Win It All?

Odds: Phillies Odds to Win World Series (+225)

The Bet: Phillies Win World Series

Analysis: At one point, picking the Phillies to win the World Series would have been the easy way out. Not so much anymore. Of the 46 “experts” Sports Illustrated asked pick the World Series winner, only 7 picked the Phillies. 3 of them picked the Phillies to not even make the playoffs.

The Phillies are becoming the victim of two things. One, over reaction to a bad spring training. Two, everybody’s sudden love affair with the Braves. It seems every year, a team is picked by experts to be a “sleeper”. But how many times do they live up to the hype? Not many. The Braves are a good team, and have a brighter future then the Phillies. But they are not better then the Phillies this season. The San Francisco Giants are a real threat to the Phillies, as both Halladay and Oswalt struggle against them.

The Phillies lost to the Giants because the bats went cold at the wrong time and Cody Ross played out of his mind. Still, if Joe Blanton does not start Game 4, who knows how that series ends. The difference this year will be Cliff Lee, who has a 3-0 record against the Giants with a 1.13 ERA. A team has not repeated as World Series Champions since 2000, and the Giants will not break that trend this year. If the Phillies do make the World Series, chances are they will face the Red Sox- who 34 of the 46 experts picks to win the World Series. The Red Sox have a dangerous line up, especially with the addition of Carl Crawford this offseason. The Phillies have more post season experience then the Red Sox, as 3 of the Big 4 pitchers have pitched in the World Series. Red Sox-Phillies would be a great series, and a chance for the Phillies to put a stamp on the 2011 season by beating a storied franchise in the Red Sox.

Will the Phillies have what it takes to overtake the Red Sox and win the World Series?

I’d bet on it.

Eliot Shorr-Parks

Read Previous

QB-Needy Teams Are Concerned About Kolb’s Salary Demands

Read Next

PETA Wants Vick Out EA Sports Madden Cover Tournament

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
April 1, 2011 8:04 am

Halladay & Oswalt struggle vs the Giants, It’s the “Phillie Lite” hitting that will doom thi Team in 2011.. WHo scare anyone outside of Howard…
This team will go as far as 3 players will take them
#1) Rollins needs a big year.. another .240 Season won’t cut it…
#2) Hamels needs to step up and show his confidence and be a top staff Pticher.. He needs to use that curve ball more in strike-out situations..
#3) Lidge Needs to get healthy and be productive and consistent

If 2 of these 3 Players bounce back and they will be fine and win the NL East. If only 1 of these 3 perform well then they squeak into the playoffs as a wildcard. If all 3, fail to perform like their capable of, then no Phillie Playoffs

April 1, 2011 8:46 am

I like the 4 deep pitching.
My concern is the bullpen and our depth in the OF.
Fransisco, Mayberry need their bats to come alive.
Rollins is in a contract year so he will be fine.
I think Blanton gets traded midseason for bullpen help and maybe an OF

92-70 is my prediction.

Milwaukee or Cincinnati make the Series vs Red Sox

April 1, 2011 8:58 am

Paulman’s Prediction in NL East

#1) Braves 93-69
#2) Phillies 90-72
#3) Marlins 82-80
#4) Nationals 75-87
#5) Mets 73-89

April 1, 2011 9:03 am

First off, to whoever wrote this, thanks for the update Captain Obvious.

2nd to Paulman: They play the Giants 6 times this year, so who cares about that until the playoffs. The Phils Lite lineup started last year. Everyone had a sub-par season. Check the stats for each Philly in comparison to past years especially the bearded one who for some reason no one thinks that we can replace. Francisco in a full season will put up comparable stats to Werth from last year. Rollins and Victo had down years especially in batting average. Utley struggled and so did Ibanez. Polanco was consistent, but he a lot. This team is going to struggle to score runs, but they did last year too and they still won 97 games last year. So Lidge is a question mark? Not exactly a news flash there.

Worried about Hamels?
2010 stats: 208 IP 3.06 ERA 211Ks
I am not worried about Hamels.

The big difference from this year to last year is Oswalt for a full season and Cliff Lee. This also translates to Blanton as the 5th starter instead of Kendrick which is better overall as well. I think that a conservative prediction of wins for all 5 starters is 73 (Halladay 18, Lee 15, Oswalt 15, Hamels 15, Blanton 10) That will easily translate to mid 90s wins.

And they will feast on the Marlins, Nats and Mets while splitting games with the Braves whose lineup is strong, but don’t have a scary staff outside of Hanson.

Am I scared about he bullpen? Absolutely, but I was last year too.

When will we get your Braves winning the NL East prediction like last year?

April 1, 2011 9:28 am

The Braves Pitching Staff from top to bottom is better than the Phils,
They will only need 6 Innings a game from their Starters since their Bullpen
is so dominant, meanwhile the Phils will need 8 Innings consisitently from their Starters and outside of a dominating Halladay, I don’t see the others pitching that deep consistently and if they do, then they will tire, and fade down the stretch being being over-pitched the first few months of the Season.. The Phils Batting line-up is their weakest in years in terms of power and hitting average.. Unless all these players you mention have bounce back years (Rollins,Victorino,Ibanez,Polanco,Utley) then they are in great shape, but the reality is that all of these players are now a year older and really are past their prime and on the downside of their careers,so I think
last years numbers, by these players, is more indictative of their abilities at this stage of their careers.. This core of players have played a lot of games over the last 4-5 years and it’s caught up to them and their bodies just don’t repsond,bounce back like it used to when their were 28-30 years old
I am going to call this Phillie Line-up “Phillie LIte” until proven otherwise..

April 1, 2011 1:10 pm

Well, as long as your predictions turn out like last year, I am fine. (you pick the Braves and the Phils win)

I would like for you to explain to me how the pitching staff is better top to bottom.

Halladay > Lowe (not even close)
Lee = Hanson (that is being generous
Oswalt = Hudson (both past their primes and injury risks)
Hamels > Jurjens (not even close)
Blanton = Beachy (I guess)

The Phils starting 5 pitched average closer to 7 IP (6.81) per start contrasted with the Braves staff at close to 6 IP (6.1). Lowe went his standard 5 2/3 yesterday.

And I guess that you think that the Phils SP will tire but the top 4 all pitched over 200 innings last year with Halladay throwing 250. He still had enough juice to throw a no-hitter in the playoffs.

If you want to say that the Braves bullpen is stronger than I agree with you, but the starting pitching is not even close. I know that you wear Braves colored glasses, but that is one of the more ridiculous statements that you have made. Put the tomahawk down.

And about the lineup, even if they produce like they did last year, the SPs are so much better than last year, it will even out.

April 1, 2011 2:53 pm

This “Philly Lite” batting line-up is AAA Level and the Bullpen is a disaster,
This 2011 Team may finish worse than I originally thought and I don’t care if
Halladay could pitch every game, you still need to hit and put the ball in play and score some runs to have a chance.. .

April 1, 2011 4:37 pm

paul, you can call them what ever you want. The batting just won a baseball game – that’s all I care about.

April 1, 2011 6:30 pm

LOL, Paulman was burned. Looks stupid once again. If I was proven wrong again and again, I wouldn’t even post here anymore out of embarrassment, but that is just me. Some people live in fantasy worlds where they convince themselves they are right even when the facts are punching them in the face saying they are wrong.

April 1, 2011 6:48 pm

pauli, for the record, I wasn’t trying to be mean here, just point out to you and scorp that (at least for this game), the negativity and fortune telling proved off point. Look on the bright side, if you live in a fantasy world, that’s an improvement from former conjectures that you live in your mom’s basement. I’d take fantasy world over parents basement any day.

April 2, 2011 10:12 pm

Philly Lite lineup = 14 runs in 2 games
Braves = 5 runs in 2 games

Overrated, clap, clap, clap clap clap.

April 3, 2011 1:12 am

bugzhawk, bravo, amen