• May 17, 2022

Notes From The Phillies’ Losses To Cincinnati

Jimmy RollinsThe Philadelphia Phillies lost both of their games against the Cincinnati Reds today, falling 1-0 in the conclusion of Wednesday’s suspended game and 11-2 in the regularly scheduled game. Their record now stands at 6-9.

  • First let’s go over the good news from these two games. Kyle Kendrick tossed seven scoreless innings last night, and Antonio Bastardo continued his strong play with a scoreless frame of his own. And that’s all of the positives.
  • Two more absolutely embarrassing performances from the offense. Two runs in two games? What’s even worse is that the two pitchers that they faced were a couple of fourth and fifth starters, Homer Bailey and Mike Leake.
  • These hitters are going up the plate without a plan right now, and they aren’t even trying to give good at-bats. The fact that Bailey made it through eight innings on just 89 pitches and Leake got through seven on 81 speaks volumes about how poor the approach of this lineup as a group is. They swing early, they swing often, they swing at ridiculous pitches. They don’t work the count, they’re not patient, the don’t walk. No one in this lineup managed a single walk over these last two games off of these mediocre pitchers. Absolutely disgraceful.
  • At the top of the order, Ben Revere is failing as the leadoff man. He went 0-8 in these two games, and is now batting just .194.
  • Jimmy Rollins has just one hit in his last 18 at-bats.
  • To make matters worse, John Lannan was crushed by the Reds lineup. Lannan couldn’t make it out of the second inning, and gave up six runs on eight hits.
  • Oh, and Raul Valdes has got to go. He was the first man out of the bullpen to relieve Lannan, and he made matters worse by allowing five runs of his own over 3.1 innings.

Final Thoughts

The Phillies need to figure this thing out quickly.

After watching this lineup fail miserably to score runs against the Marlins, and perform even worse against the Reds, its time for Charlie Manuel to move some pieces around and shake things up.

Manuel has stated before that with his current roster, the amount of moves he can make in the lineup is limited until he gets Carlos Ruiz and Delmon Young back. He doesn’t want to move Michael Young out of the five-hole because he doesn’t have another reliable right-handed bat to protect Ryan Howard. He wants to give Ben Revere a chance to settle in and emerge as a good leadoff hitter.

But right now things just aren’t working. This lineup is dead and needs some kind of shakeup. Even if it’s just for a game or two, I think Manuel needs to do something.

My suggested lineup?

1. Jimmy Rollins

2. Michael Young

3. Chase Utley

4. Ryan Howard

5. John Mayberry

6. Domonic Brown

7. Ben Revere

8. Erik Kratz

Obviously this lineup is far from ideal, but no combination that Manuel could possibly put together is ideal right now and here’s my reasoning behind it. Again, this isn’t a lineup I’d want the Phils to move switch to everyday, but just as a temporary measure to try and create some new energy.

  • Putting Rollins back at leadoff gets the struggling Revere out of there, and puts Jimmy back in the spot where he’s most comfortable.
  • Michael Young is an ideal two-hole hitter for the team when Ruiz and Delmon Young return, moving him there gives the team a much more stable hitter in the top of the order.
  • Young’s move to the top of the order creates a need for a right-handed hitter behind Ryan Howard to break up the lefties, and Mayberry is the best fit for that role right now.
  • Revere hitting seventh allows him to get out of the leadoff spot, and if he can get on base, his speed and ability to steal could help reduce the possibility of Erik Kratz grounding into double-plays.

Denny Basens

Read Previous

Only Took Ten Minutes To Prove Another Manuel Gaffe

Read Next

Brent Celek on Chip Kelly’s Communication System: “it’s going to change the league”


  • Notes from the Phillies losses- They suck, like I said they would! Can’t hit. Can’t score. Mediocre pitching. Too old. Howard, not coming even close to his contract. Rollins, never shows up when you need him. Brown back to his normal, non-factor self. Revere nothing but speed & a glove. BOOBEN NEEDS TO GO! NOW! At this rate, we’ll be sellers by May! No debating it now boys! I don’t want to hear it’s early anymore, BLAH, BLAH, BLAH! They are what I said they are! Band-aids, holding back a hemorrhage! GTFO!

  • I’ll be awaiting the excuse makers, with their built in excuse now, with Brown & Lannan hurt. GTFO!

  • I bought would battle and win 84-85 Games,
    These next 8 Games tell the tale versus the slugging Cards and the improved Pirates.. They go 2-6 or 3-5 over this Homestand
    Then it’s all over for them for they will be 9-10 games back
    By the end of April. In predict Charlie Manuel will be fired at the end of the Homestand.. Huge 8 Games for 2013 Season and for Manuel..

  • Domonic Brown is scheduled to undergo an MRI on his sore mid-back Thursday in Philadelphia.
    Brown was pulled from Wednesday night’s game in Cincinnati after experiencing some back stiffness. “I don’t know what happened,” said the 25-year-old outfielder. “We’re going to get an MRI and see exactly what’s going on. I don’t think it’s anything major at all.”

  • When is the true culprit, of the construction & destruction of this horrid, putrid team, going to be held responsible?!? Booben is the 1, who should be the 1st to get axed, not Charlie. But, as we know, the lame duck Manager, gets whacked 1st. He won us a WS, not Booben, the inept, imbecile, GM!

  • Phillies placed LHP John Lannan on the 15-day disabled list with a strained left quadriceps muscle.
    Lannan suffered the injury Wednesday while allowing six runs over just 1 2/3 innings against the Reds. He has a 6.14 ERA and 7/2 K/BB ratio in 14 2/3 total frames this season. It’s not clear how long he will be out.

    Adam Morgan not Tyler Cloyd please

    • I paulmadamus that dcar will post I told you so about Lannan

      • I told you so!

  • 5 IP 2 Hits against morgan today.

    • Meanwhile Kyle Loshe in Milwaukee 3 Starts and 3 Quality Starts
      20 Innings Pitched 6 Earned Runs for a 2.70 ERA… Loshe has always been a Fast Starter and comes out of the Gate really Strong in April,MAy & June..

  • paulman April 18, 2013 -4:01 pm Meanwhile Kyle Loshe in Milwaukee 3 Starts and 3 Quality Starts 20 Innings Pitched 6 Earned Runs for a 2.70 ERA… Loshe has always been a Fast Starter and comes out of the Gate really Strong in April,MAy & June.


    Amaro may not be going, but Charlie is: soon.

Comments are closed.