• December 9, 2022

The Concussion Pandemic & Possible Solutions

While the hockey community deals with the shocking news that Captain Chris Pronger will be out for the rest of the season, many are left wondering how can the game become safer.  While it is tough to protect players from situations where a stick accidentally clips their face ( Pronger ) or a teammate’s knee ( Claude Giroux), there are plenty of ways of protecting those who sustain a concussion. While I am not advocating that all of the ways I mention should happen, just that the league needs to consider them.

First, years ago in the NHL players did not wear elbow pads with gigantic hard plastic protection over the elbow.  The elbow pads used to be smaller and lighter. While some would argue the harder elbow pads offer much more protection, cut down on the size of hard plastic or changing it back to the old foam pads would certainly help in minimizing concussions from errant elbows.

In addition to reducing the size of elbow pads, the NHL needs to start investing significant money in more protective helmets. Both the MLB and NFL have come up with helmets that are supposed to reduce the risk of concussion. This to me would be the biggest no brainer out there. Reduce the risk of a concussion just by changing the way a helmet is made? Slam dunk win.

Next up, how about reinstating the two-line pass? This would immediately cut down on incidents racing for a puck to cancel out an icing. Gone would be a lot of ugly injuries we have increasingly seen over the last couple of years. Detractors would clearly say that the two-line pass was abolished to increase offense. This would be hard to reestablish with Gary Bettman as commissioner, but should be strongly considered. It would not only cut down on concussions, but any sort of injury that could occur from such a play.

Another rule that should be revised is the fact that clutching and grabbing by defenseman needs to be allowed again. Without it, we see situations where speedy guys racing down the ice, instead of getting a quick grab to slow them down, fly freely by.  When a defensemen accidently trips them up, the results can be scary. Slowing down an incoming forward, momentarily, allows both the forwards and defensemen involved to still stay involved in the play. Once again, those against this proposal will state that offensive production may slip with clutching and grabbing being legalized again.

Finally, my most radical proposal—changing rink dimensions to the larger dimensions similar to those rinks in Europe.  In North America, rink size is 200 feet by 85 feet. European rinks are 200 feet by 98 feet.  An extra 13 feet in the width of the ice! This extra space would allow more room for all 10 skaters on the ice at one time. This extra space would also allow for players to escape from the punishment of violent contact. By no means do I want to see big hits gone from the game at all, but the added room will do wonders for protecting players while not changing the rules of the game. This change might even increase offensive output. I believe that while this is the most radical of the changes, it might be the most beneficial in terms of appeasing those who don’t want to go back to any old rules abolished, but want to see more done about the concussion issue.

Mike Joachim

Huge flyers fan and a huge fan of rock music

Read Previous

Phillies – A Long Shot For Michael Cuddyer

Read Next

Good Time For College Football: It’s Bowl Season

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Tech Triumph
Tech Triumph
December 16, 2011 8:29 am

I understand the desire to reduce concussions, but bringing back clutching and grabbing goes much too far. This is an entertainment business and there are some risks that are required to actually entertain. The clutching and grabbing would send folks racing for the exits. I don’t even know that’s a valid reason why these concussions are happening.

The forward are not involved in the play with clutching and grabbing. Dump in, defenseman holds up puck dumper, other defenseman gets puck and clears zone. It’s awful to watch and there is a product to actually sell.

December 16, 2011 9:33 am

More Space causes more speed which probably leads to bigger Collisions.. Maybe their won’t be as many hits, but the hits would probably be bigger and harder due to players having more speed,momentum behind them..
Hockey like all sports just has a Physical Nature to the game that Injuries are going to occur and then when you add Sticks,Frozen Pucks, with the speed and power that todays bigger,stronger athletes Concussions are going to happen ,more often and especialyl when the awareness of head injuries are at an all time high in sports like we see in Football..

December 16, 2011 9:33 am

No way we can go back to clutching and grabbing. I think that you have to come down harder on the boarding and elbowing penalties where players are clearly trying to hurt other players. Look at what has happened to Crosby. I hate him, but he is a once in a generation talent who is gonna have his career shortened because everybody takes runs at him.

December 16, 2011 9:58 am

Cosby, is just like Eagles QB M Vick, every defender hits him just a little harder and it takes a toll…

December 16, 2011 11:28 am


Hockey pads are insane today. Elbow pads end in some composite plastic material, that meets at a point. Anyone with an understanding of grade 8 mathematics understands that the force exerted from the end of one of these new pads has been multiplied due to the smaller surface area. That combined that they (and shoulder pads) now made of unweildingly tough material is directly leading to the increase of head trauma.

It is reaching the youth level at an alarming rate, with 2 of my neighbours and friends having taken their kids out due to their having concussions. Its to the point where I am seriously considering not registering my youngest next year….(of course I will, but will really have to weigh the pros/cons of continuing into his teens when contact allowed)

I played by whole life with padding on my pads. So did everyone else I grew up with. Did I ever get my bell rung? Sure…And I took a couple of elboes to the noggin…..but the pads were designed to absorb the impact. Pads today are designed to amplify the impact.

December 17, 2011 9:11 am

My solutions-
1- Better helmets re-enforced with kevlar & removable memory foam (no pun intended).
2- Mandatory visors.
3- All blatant hits to the head & boarding penalties are punishable by 20 game suspensions.
4- Icing should automatically be whistled, without touch-up.
5- (I know this won’t be popular) Ban fighting. No one fights in the playoffs & it protects teams from wasting $$$ & roster spots on guys like Shelly, Carcillo, Cote, etc. etc.
No to clutching & grabbing. No to changing padding, because it protects breaking bones. Hell no to the red-line.